Philosophy Class

"The Truth will make you odd."

Jeremy Bentham's Utilitarianism

UTILITARIANISM

Jeremy Bentham Englishman 1748 to 1832.

1. Mankind is governed by pleasure and pain. (We are not talking about justice and injustice here, as did Aristotle)

2. No matter what you say they dominate all we do.

3. Must assume this for foundation of ANY ethical system.

4. Approve or not of any ACTION measured by how an act augments or diminishes happiness of one whose interest is in question. p. 28

5. Likewise for government action. Whether it augments or diminishes interest of a community.

(produce benefit, advantage, pleasure, good, happiness.)

6. Interest of a community is the sum of interests of several members who compose it.

7. For an individual, it promotes interest for HIM. The action adds to sum total of his pleasures, or diminishes sum total of his pain.

8. He says it is unnecessary to prove this theory, for no one has ever disproved it . We assume it.

9.Bentham says all of us use these principles in action.

10. Total sum of pleasure and pain in a community would judge if some act is good. (Aristotle - justice. Bentham - utility)

If there is more pain than pleasure, not good. "Hedonic calculus".

11. Read the section and you will get more details.

12. If you go to "University college" in London, you can see Bentham's embalmed body dressed in his customary clothes.

13. Read p. 281 encyc. of philos. under Bentham

14. Others forms of this right is judged if the action causes more pleasure to the sum total of life forms.

wrong is that the action causes more pain than pleasure to the sum total of life forms.

15. Read to the students p. 281. under Bentham, encyclopedia of Philosophy. (taking nephew to circus).

 

 

Critique

1. How do we of all the pleasure and pain measure how much there is? Ask this of a Benthamite...

2. When asked by someone what would prevent a majority of Englishmen from killing a minority, if it were deemed useful, Bentham stated, "Englishmen wouldn't behave like that."

3. Word pleasure is ambiguous. (equivocal)

4. One may take happiness from pleasure of others, and then one may not . What about the one who revels in the pain of others?

5. Dr. Cohen said he tried Bentham's ideas at home for a week; he concluded they did not work..

6. Mr. Bentham lives in a Christian English society. He is a product of western civilization. He and others are living by custom and training these principles.

7. If his ideas are tried in another society, say the critics, they would be disastrous.

8. Who knows how future Englishmen will behave in future under different moral system and training and desires.

9. Remember, Communists adopted this ethic, "Whatever advances the Revolution is moral." Revolution and bloodshed of anyone necessary is compensated by future advantages. Lenin said  "You have to break a few eggs to get an omlette.

Remember: accept an action if it augments pleasure diminishes pain.    

Deny an action if it augments pain and diminishes pleasure (for those involved).

 

Thomas Aquinas, Natural Law

1. Remember the end justifies the means?

 

3. How Thomas Aquinas figured out moral law. 

He does not believe that the end justifies the

means.

 

4. There is an eternal law which applies to all

men, just because they are men,

 

5. Aristotle said the moral law was the same for

all of the same nature.

Example: What law does a dog follow to be a

good properly functioning law.

 

6. Because a human being is a rational animal,

he MUST act rationally.

 

8. The eternal law is in the mind of God along w/

man's nature.

 

9. How does one follow the eternal law.

 

10. The natural law: it may be figured out by

reason.

 

11. However, people make mistakes in their

reasoning. Hence the 10 Commandments.

 

12. The basic principles of the natural law:

 

13. First principle:

No one is ignorant of this: Do good. Avoid evil.

 

14. Second principle

General principles of the moral law.. As in the 10

Commandments.

example: Thou shalt not steal.

 

Mistakes may be made by application in

particular situations because of the fact that

humans make mistakes in their reasoning. This

is because the passions effect us too much.

 

15. Tertiary principles

They take a lot of long reasoning to arrive at

these. Hence mistakes are multitudinous in

history. Example: polygamy is wrong.

 

16. Now, how, as Jeremy Bentham tried to figure

out by calculus, how are we to figure what to

do?

 

17 Aquinas says this:

 

18. We are only talking about Human Acts.

 

19. What are Human Acts? They are acts freely

done.

 

20. Human acts can be good, evil, or neutral.

(whistling going down the street is neutral.)

 

21. How do we find out if acts are evil or good?

 

22. Each human act has

     1. an object  

     2. a Motive

     3. Surrounding circumstances (can make

         the act

 

worse Example: Murder of a man vs. murder of

your father. The fact that he is your father

makes it worse. Patricide. You are not only

violating the right to life, you are violating your

duty in justice to your parents.)

 

23. Object is the thing done. Example: A man

steals from another. The stealing is the object.

 

24. He has a motive for stealing. He wants to

buy a Corvette. Or he wants to give money to

the poor.

 

25. Aquinas said that both motive and object

be good or act is bad. Also circumstances effect.

 

26. Example:

Murder a rich Uncle in order to get his money for

your sick child.

 

1. motive: get money for a sick child. GOOD

   object: murder uncle BAD conclusion: whole

   thing is bad.

 

2. motive : to make others think you are good

when your are secretly evil BAD.

Object: giving alms to the poor. Good

conclusion: whole thing is bad

 

3. Motive: to get money for your sick child

Act: ask you rich uncle conclusion : good thing

all around.

 

 

Thomas Aquinas: Medieval

Aquinas' famous Summa

Theologica Aquinas on Love and Selfishness

         

            Selfish and unselfish

 

Selfish - love for the pleasure it gives YOU.

This is selfish love

This is Love of concupiscence.

 

Man loves another by desiring only GOOD of

the other.

 

Love is unselfish man for man (man for

woman. Woman for man, etc.)

This is the love of friendship.

Selfish love is NOT evil.

It urges man to self happiness that God has

intended for him.

 

Love of friendship is nobler.

This love grows in the lives of others sharing

their life activities.

 

Man rises above himself by mingling with

other lives. that is lives of the

a. human

b. angelic

c. Divine

 

Love is caused by knowledge.

 

Unless an object is known, (love) attraction

cannot occur.

 

The knowledge may not be perfect

knowledge to cause love.

 

Goodness is the basic cause of love. (We are

attracted to the GOOD in something.)

 

The good satisfies our appetite.

 

We are attracted by likeness.

 

When men are alike in virtues, tastes,

abilities, they tend to union w/one another.

 

When opposites attract, attraction comes

from what is alike in each of the opposites.

 

All love leads to union with the beloved.

 

Man loves a woman, so he longs for her

presence.

 

Love is ecstatic

 

He will think less of himself

 

He will sacrifice for the beloved.

 

Jealously flows from love.He resents rivals.

 

Question: to love other people:

 

                   Do you do everything for them and give them everything.

                   or not?

                   When is it just to sacrifice yourself for others?

_______________________________________________________________________________

EVIL according to Aquinas To him evil exists in the object, not originated in the mind.

 

Thomas Aquinas: heights of the Middle Ages Intellectual development. Golden Age of Medieval times. 1224 to 1274

 

1. Moderns sometimes erroneously believe that the medieval times were totally benighted.

 

2. The truth is in philosophical and other areas, and we are only speaking of philosophical areas, not religious, or even architectural or artistic, there was cultural and intellectual development which surpassed that of the Golden Age of Greece.

3. Here, in medieval philosophy, was the roots of what we call "modern science".

 

4. It developed out of a new discovery at this time of the works of Aristotle which were unappreciated in the west, because of the lack of good translations of same, an misinterpretation of Aristotle, and other reasons like the attachment to the ideas of Plato (remember the early centuries AD?)

 

5. Aquinas wrote his treatise on evil to "settle the Manichees"

 

6. His analysis is totally metaphysical.

 

7. First he analyses the notion of being itself.

 

8. He says BEING = GOOD. All being is good.

 

9. We will not do this here, but he discusses the attributes of God.

eternal, immutable, perfect.

 

10. He says, "God is not only his own essence but his own existence."

 

11. Next he discusses goodness in general

 

12. His first question is "Whether goodness differs really from Being?"

 

13. "Goodness and being are really the same, and differ only in idea".

 

14. "Goodness is what all desire"

 

15. "Goodness presents the aspect of desirableness which being does not present."

 

16. "Therefore, being has goodness, because it has being."

 

17. God the cause of all being has all goodness.

 

18. "Every being that is not God is God's creature."

 

19. "Creatures also possess goodness in deriving goodness from God>"

 

20. "Every creature of God is good."

 

21. "God is the greatest good."

 

22. "In the greatest good, evil is not present"

 

23. So we must wait till the "Treatise on Creation" to find where evil is discussed..

 

24. We can only understand evil after we understand good.

 

25. He poses the question: "Whether evil is found in things"

 

26. "Perfection of the universe requires that there should be some which can fail in

goodness"

 

27. "Evil is that a thing fails in goodness."

 

28. "Hence...evil is found in things, for corruption is itself an evil." "Evil is absence of

good in a being which should possess that good."

 

29. "We know now that evil is not a specific Being." (Manichees)

 

30. "The essence of evil is failure."

 

31. There are 2 kinds of absence of good:

                1. One would be a non-privative absence. EX: Lack of sight in a stone

 

                2. Lack of perfection in a being which should by its nature possess this perfection. 

Example: Blindness in a man.

 

32. Privation presupposes evil exists in good beings.

 

33. Evil exists as in a subject.

 

34. There is evil of pain and fault in rational creatures.

                1. pain - withdraw of the due operation in a being EX: Getting a broken leg or cancer, etc.

                2. Evil of fault in rational creatures. "Subtraction of due operation in voluntary things has the nature of fault." Moral evil is chosen freely. (Remember Aristotle's properly functioning man. It was his choice to pursue virtue or not.) (Free will is dealt with in another section)